The Surrey Trophy
This trophy was initially awarded annually for the best shark of the season by a Member resident in Surrey. in 2018 the challenge was amended to the runner up to the Alan Caunter Trophy
| Year | Name | Species | Estimated Weight |
| 2021 | Angela Spearing | Blue | 86.8lbs |
| 2020 | n/a | ||
| 2019 | n/a | ||
| 2018 | Angela Spearing | Blue | 74.5lbs |
| 2017 | Richard Young | Blue | 100lbs |
| 2015 | John Lock | Blue | 80.5lbs |
| 2012 | M Nethersole | Blue | |
| 2011 | M Morgan | Blue | |
| 2002 | Richard Young | Blue | 78lbs |
| 1997 | G Boyt | Blue | 106lbs |
| 1994 | S Staniford | Blue | 109lbs |
| 1992 | A Thomas | Blue | 100.5lbs |
| 1990 | V S Gray & C Sinclair | Blue | 99lbs |
| 1989 | S Staniford | Blue | 92lbs |
| 1988 | J Scott | Blue | 87lbs |
| 1986 | S Staniford | Blue | 94lbs |
| 1984 | S Staniford | Blue | 92lbs |
| 1981 | M H St. J Sharp | Porbeagle | 175lbs |
| 1980 | W Foster | Blue | 86lbs |
| 1978 | R I Cottrell | Porbeagle | 450lbs |
| 1977 | Mrs D Butler | Porbeagle | 208lbs |
| 1976 | Dr. Gamal Hamza | Porbeagle | 220lbs |
| 1975 | W G Bowry | Thresher | 241lbs |
| 1974 | R King | Blue | 96lbs |
| 1973 | R King | Blue | 85lbs |
| 1972 | R King | Blue | 91lbs |
| 1971 | R King | Blue | 78lbs |
| 1970 | R King | Blue | 93lbs |
| 1969 | R King | Blue | 107lbs |